VAT Budget Cuts and the UK Economy

VAT Budget Cuts and the UK Economy

Trading Features / Strategies from Simon Denham of Capital Spreads.

Pre-Budget

The leaks on what will be announced in the Pre-Budget announcement sum up the absolute paucity of both the country and in political and economic thinking in the top echelons of government.

The madness of an ever greater public sector funded, in an ever increasing proportion, by a booming service sector at the expense of a weakening manufacturing division had been pointed out ad-nauseam by various commentators over the past ten years. The huge tax revenues created by the tsunami of, not necessarily cheap but definitely, accessible funds lulled the Treasury, the Government and the population as a whole into a false sense that we had created a stable economic foundation.

Now that the chickens are coming home to roost we have the rather unnerving vision of the Chancellor and the Prime Minister scrabbling around trying to think of ever more dramatic ways of keeping us going to the shops every weekend. Is this all we have been reduced to?

Amidst all this woe one gem has arisen out of the muck. The proposed reduction in VAT has been a long time coming and might also focus minds on what has become one of the most pernicious brakes on economic growth it is possible to come up with. VAT is a tax at point of sale and as a consequence has a multiplier effect throughout its chain.

To understand this we must look (simplistically I admit) at the economics of Government fiscal stimuli. If the State borrows to fund a project the idea is that this will have an effect through the economy far greater than the initial sum spent. £1bn spent will then be spent again and again in an ever decreasing spiral as salaries get spent, profits get reinvested, so the next business down the line then also pay salaries, builds more capacity etc etc...as tax and external spending (imports) take their toll on the original sum so the effect reduces but the intention is obvious and the overall impact is reckoned to be many times the initial spend. “The Multiplier Effect”.

VAT is a curious item in that it is almost the exact opposite of a multiplier stimulus. Its effect is almost that of a series of tiny little brakes at every level.

It is charged and offset by a myriad of businesses across the country, as I get charged VAT so I charge it to somebody else, he then charges his VAT services to someone else and so on and so on until (at some point in the year) I sum up the difference in all these little numbers and pay it on to the VAT man.

A reduction in VAT from 17.5% to 15% should have an impact way beyond its decrease in the tax take particularly as it is an upfront reduction rather than a lagging one as is the case with most tax cuts.

Unfortunately in other areas the Government has once again reverted to type and gone down the easy route in projected spending projects. The proposed increases (or bringing forward) in capital expenditure plans once again bear the tag “NHS and Education”.

I am sorry, but spending vast sums, in tough times, on schemes that will do nothing for the medium term prosperity of the nation are once again building up long term indebtedness.

Financial Spreads » "With FinancialSpreads.com you get all the normal
advantages of Spread Betting plus..." » read Financial Spreads review.

Can anyone name a major infrastructure build that has taken place in the last ten years? No new roads /airports / railways / power stations / sewage plants / water works the list goes on.

All we see are repeated mend and make do as political will has virtually disappeared. A definition of success for politicians in the UK is to still be in power, not to have made the right decisions. In an effort to appease virtually everyone the easy route (spend on the ‘now’ and sod the future) has become almost a mantra.

Admittedly it is easy to denigrate without constructive comment. I do not have a myriad of concerns to ameliorate. Unfortunately this government is once again making decisions to help it win the next election not to dramatically help the UK economy and “bugger the electoral consequences”.

Many of the expected stimuli seem to be of the order of cancellation of future tax rises. Quite how these are supposed to aid an economy already reeling under the existing weight of the slowing economic juggernaut is difficult to imagine but I suppose it makes for a good headline.

The increase in Government Guarantees on small business loans sounds great but what does it actually mean? Banks do not stop lending for the fun of it. They have to make decisions on where to lend “Other People's Money”. Banks borrow from solvent small businesses, wealthy individuals, other financial institutions and, yes, you and me and then lend it (at a higher rate) to somebody else.

If I am going to trust a bank with my money I want to be sure that they are making the right decisions on who to lend to. Their remit is to the continuance of strong lending criteria, building a solid balance sheet, paying their shareholders (remember them) not some strange beast called “the public interest”.

Browbeating from the Chancellor to throw good money after bad is not conducive to sensible decision taking. The fact that the public purse has been used to fund rights issues is not pertinent. We would be horrified if the Sovereign funds who have invested in the capital raising programmes over the past year or so used their share holdings to manipulate the banks concerned lending criteria so why should we expect it to be any different with state funds. The banks may have made truly dire choices in some investment areas over the past few years but this is not in the small business arena.

Unfortunately as with Gordon Brown’s mirage of an “end to boom and bust” the idea that he can come up with some new way out of a recession by spending a few billion here and there is pure fantasy. The cupboard is bare and I fear that the downturn this time is going to make the eighties and nineties recessions pale into insignificance. The dead hand of the public sector is now so much of a drag on the economy that it will probably take some extreme measures to offset. New analysis shows that two thirds of all the ‘new jobs’ created in the UK since 1997 rely on government largesse in one form or another. This is the legacy of Tony and Gordon and it is one that we will all rue for many, many years to come.

The above comments do not constitute investment advice and neither Capital Spreads nor Clean Financial accept any responsibility for any use that may be made of them.

Capital Spreads » "With Capital Spreads you get all the normal
advantages of Spread Betting plus..." » read Capital Spreads review.

Risk Warning: Spread betting carries a high level of risk to your capital. You may lose more than your initial investment. It may not be suitable for all investors. Only speculate with money that you can afford to lose. Please ensure you fully understand the risks involved and seek independent financial advice where necessary.

Article provided / approved by Capital Spreads which is a trading name of London Capital Group Ltd which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority (FSA), FSA Register number 182110.

'VAT Budget Cuts and the UK Economy' edited by DB, updated 24-Nov-08

Related Articles:

Banking Sector Value Shares, updated 18-Mar-08
Rumours that Lehman might be the next in line for implosion after DB Singapore apparently refused their name in the money markets were quickly quashed. The stock was at one point some 50pc down on the day at around $20.50 but later bounced as investment banks...read article: Banking Sector Value Shares.

Job Cuts, School Finance and Career Politicians, updated 13-Mar-08
Cowardice in high places is not a new phenomena but this administrations spinelessness is now beginning to show as bright yellow streak across the finance of UK plc. Yet another Budget long on raising revenue but short on...read article: Job Cuts, School Finance and Career Politicians.

Finance Lesson from Japan, updated 12-Mar-08
So, the Fed and the ECB are now both taking dodgy mortgage debt as collateral against loans. One wonders how closely these deposits will be checked for value or will the western banks end up in the same boat as the Japanese financial institutions from the early nineties sitting with huge unrealised losses on 20-30 year loans being...read article: Finance Lesson from Japan.

Recession or Value Shares, updated 11-Mar-08
As markets get tougher so the wolves begin to strike. Bear Stearns and Lehman were forced into swift denunciations after rumours circulated about possible Chapter 11 situations. Whilst the security of the companies is not reasonably in doubt the mere mention of weakness will have its negative effect. Twitchy depositors, fearful of losing substantial sums will...read article: Recession or Value Shares.

AAA Rated Government Insurance, updated 10-Mar-08
Most people reading this article will be of the 40% paying slice of the population, the bit that the government is relying on, to an increasing extent, to balance its books. The taxes on virtually everything we do are now getting to...read article: AAA Rated Government Insurance.

Slow Down, Interest Rates and Goodbye London, updated 09-Mar-08
We saw the knee jerk US political reaction to the Enron collapse seriously damage their financial industry by its implementation of the Sarbannes Oxley requirements and it is beginning to look as though the UK authorities are going to make the same mistake. What is the betting on...read article: Slow Down, Interest Rates and Goodbye London.

Commodities Price Correction, updated 06-Mar-08
Other commodities are, likewise, not exactly *running out* (although copper is reputed to be looking a tad thin on the ground) and *softs* are an accident waiting to happen. As one product becomes ever more expensive so our food...read article: Commodities Price Correction.

Second Class Financial Ticket, updated 04-Mar-08
With a snarling up of basic transport lines business will look elsewhere to invest. We might pride ourselves on the power of the financial sector in the city of London but finance is probably the most portable business on the planet. The logistics of moving money around could not be simpler. HSBC yesterday showed that some 50% of revenue...read article: Second Class Financial Ticket.

Credit Crunch Finance, updated 04-Mar-08
Is this the second leg of the credit crunch? The rush into *secure* havens has accelerated over the past few weeks as US Treasury Bond yields slip below 2% and Gold and other Precious metals reach for the sky. Borrowing spreads for even high quality corporate names are at, what appear to be, ridiculous levels as banks scrabble to cover lending exposures in the money markets. Whilst the sharp point of this...read article: Credit Crunch Finance.

Private Equity Trading, updated 29-Feb-08
If the credit crunch continues for much longer, many of the deals that companies had been expecting to offload via stock market floats could start to experience certain problems. Given that a number of them will now be coming up for rollover of their initial financing deals, in a dog eat dog environment it does...read article: Private Equity Trading.

First Page << 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 >> Last Page

Also see:

Trading Features / Strategies Index – an index of all the Trading Features.

Q) Average Trading Results?

A) Get free trading tips, offers, price updates, important news and more! All Free - Click here!

Risk Warning: Spread betting and CFD trading carry a high level of risk to your capital and you may lose more than your initial investment. Spread betting and CFD trading may not be suitable for all investors. Only speculate with money that you can afford to lose. Please ensure you fully understand the risks involved and seek independent financial advice where necessary.

The contents on CleanFinancial.com are for information purposes only and are not intended as a recommendation to trade. Nothing on this website should be construed as investment advice.

Neither CleanFinancial.com nor any contributing company/author accept any responsibility for any use that may be made of the above or for the correctness or accuracy of the information provided.

* Tax law is subject to change or may differ if you pay tax in a jurisdiction other than the UK.

1) Daily Trading Tips

2) Financial Tips

3) Financial Tipping